CheckMark Payroll vs Paycor: Which Payroll Software Is Better?

Disclosure: We may earn commissions if you shop through the links below.
Last Updated: April 25, 2025

Both CheckMark Payroll and Paycor are leading payroll software solutions, but which one is better for you and your business?

Below we compare CheckMark Payroll and Paycor across nearly 50 different data points to help you make find the right one.

CheckMark Payroll vs Paycor Reviews

		CheckMark Payroll	Paycor
Trustpilot Rating		3.5	1.8
Number of Trustpilot Reviews		0	26
iPhone App Rating		not available	4.7
Number of iPhone App Reviews		not available	22800
Android App Rating		not available	3.7
Number of Android App Reviews		not available	29200

CheckMark Payroll vs Paycor Pricing

	CheckMark Payroll	Paycor
Free Trial	Yes	Yes
Free Trial Length	2 months	1 month
Cheapest Plan Name	CheckMark Payroll Pro	Basic
Cheapest Plan Cost Per Month	$n/a	$By request
Mid Priced Plan Name	n/a	Core
Mid Priced Plan Cost Per Month	$n/a	$By request
Top Plan Name	CheckMark Payroll Pro+	Complete
Top Plan Cost Per Month	$619	$By request

CheckMark Payroll vs Paycor Features

Features	CheckMark Payroll	Paycor
Target Business Size	Mid size business	Enterprise
Unlimited Payrolls	✔	✘
Automated Tax Filing & Payments	✔	✔
E-sign I-9 & W-4	✘	✔
Live Customer Support	✔	✔
Third-Party Integrations	✔	✔
Ability To Manage Employee Benefits	✔	✔
Employee Access To Platform	✔	✔
Direct Deposit	✔	✔
Expense Reimbursement	✔	✔
Time Off Accrual	✔	✔
Pre-Tax Deductions	✔	✔
Wage Garnishment	✔	✔
Background Checks	✘	✔
Check Printing	✔	✔
Check Delivery	✘	✘
API	✘	✔

CheckMark Payroll CheckMark Payroll Pro Features

Self Service Payroll
Automatic Payroll Calculation
Unlimited Companies
Unlimited Salaried & Hourly Employees
Unlimited Payrolls (Regular, Bonus, Off-Cycle, etc.)
All Pay Frequencies
Multiple Pay Rates
MICR Encoded Check Printing
ACH Direct Deposit
Printing & E-Filing of Forms 941, 940, 944, 943, W-2, & W-3
Employer Payroll Tax Filings
Access to 40+ Types of Payroll Reports
Employee Benefits (Health, Retirement, Insurance, etc.)
Customized Vacation and Sick Leave Policies
Customized Deductions and Garnishments
Up to 90 mins within 12 months
Online access to program fixes

Paycor Basic Features

Payroll and Tax Service
Wage Garnishments
Pay Options
Off-Cycle Payruns
Check Stuffing
Online Check Stub
Online Reporting
Additional Tax Local Authorities
Additional Tax State Authorities
New Hire Filing EVS
Work Number
OnDemand Pay
Worker Opportunity Tax Credit
AutoRun

CheckMark Payroll CheckMark Payroll Pro+ Features

Self Service Payroll
Automatic Payroll Calculation
Unlimited Companies
Unlimited Salaried & Hourly Employees
Unlimited Payrolls (Regular, Bonus, Off-Cycle, etc.)
All Pay Frequencies
Multiple Pay Rates
MICR Encoded Check Printing
ACH Direct Deposit
Printing & E-Filing of Forms 941, 940, 944, 943, W-2, & W-3
Employer Payroll Tax Filings
Access to 40+ Types of Payroll Reports
Employee Benefits (Health, Retirement, Insurance, etc.)
Customized Vacation and Sick Leave Policies
Customized Deductions and Garnishments
Up to 300 mins of support within 12 months
Exclusive Pro+ toll-free phone number
Top-of-the-queue priority
Reduced data recovery rates
Online access to program fixes
Exclusive Pro+ Support Live Chat

Paycor Complete Features

CheckMark Payroll vs Paycor Pro & Cons

	CheckMark Payroll	Paycor
Pros	Direct deposit option Easy to use and interfaces with CheckMark’s Accounting program, MultiLedger Automated reports	Easy Processes User Friendly Customer Service User Interface Onboarding
Cons	Technical support, glitches with Mac High cost More features like direct sms, email, other tax purpose forms	Customer Service Not User Friendly Technical Issues Slow Reporting Issues

Other Payroll Software Comparisons

Toast vs WorkZoom

PrimePay vs Sage

greytHR vs Toast

Arbonum vs WorkZoom

APS Payroll vs Push Payroll

Remote vs Arbonum

Deel vs Hourly

Payfit vs Everee Payroll

Darwinbox vs Dayforce

Microkeeper vs Revelo