Square Payroll vs ThePayStubs: Which Payroll Software Is Better?

Both Square Payroll and ThePayStubs are leading payroll software solutions, but which one is better for you and your business?

Below we compare Square Payroll and ThePayStubs across nearly 50 different data points to help you make find the right one.

Square Payroll vs ThePayStubs Reviews

	Square Payroll	ThePayStubs
Trustpilot Rating	4.2	4.2
Number of Trustpilot Reviews	4049	585
iPhone App Rating	4.8	not available
Number of iPhone App Reviews	5	not available
Android App Rating	3.8	not available
Number of Android App Reviews	2660	not available

	Square Payroll	ThePayStubs
Free Trial	n/a	Yes
Free Trial Length	n/a	14 days
Cheapest Plan Name	Pay Contractors Only	Stub
Cheapest Plan Cost Per Month	$n/a	$n/a
Mid Priced Plan Name	n/a	n/a
Mid Priced Plan Cost Per Month	$n/a	$n/a
Top Plan Name	Pay Employees & Contractors	n/a
Top Plan Cost Per Month	$41	$n/a

Features	Square Payroll	ThePayStubs
Target Business Size	Small business	Small business
Unlimited Payrolls	✔	✘
Automated Tax Filing & Payments	✔	✘
E-sign I-9 & W-4	✘	✘
Live Customer Support	✔	✘
Third-Party Integrations	✔	✘
Ability To Manage Employee Benefits	✔	✘
Employee Access To Platform	✔	✘
Direct Deposit	✔	✘
Expense Reimbursement	✘	✘
Time Off Accrual	✔	✘
Pre-Tax Deductions	✔	✔
Wage Garnishment	✔	✔
Background Checks	✘	✘
Check Printing	✔	✘
Check Delivery	✔	✘
API	✔	✘

n/a

	Square Payroll	ThePayStubs
Pros	Mobile App Self Service User Friendly	Seamless Creation Process Round-The-Clock Customer Support Ready-Made Templates Professional Stubs For Record-Keeping
Cons	Not User Friendly Room for Improvement Slow