Switch On Business

CheckMark Payroll vs Sage: Which Payroll Software Is Better?


Disclosure: We may earn commissions if you shop through the links below.
Last Updated:

Both CheckMark Payroll and Sage are leading payroll software solutions, but which one is better for you and your business?

Below we compare CheckMark Payroll and Sage across nearly 50 different data points to help you make find the right one.

 

CheckMark Payroll vs Sage Reviews

CheckMark PayrollSage
Trustpilot Rating3.54.4
Number of Trustpilot Reviews016822
iPhone App Ratingnot available4.8
Number of iPhone App Reviewsnot available13
Android App Ratingnot available4.8
Number of Android App Reviewsnot available21300

CheckMark Payroll vs Sage Pricing

CheckMark PayrollSage
Free TrialYesYes
Free Trial Length2 months1 month
Cheapest Plan NameCheckMark Payroll ProPayroll
Cheapest Plan Cost Per Month$n/a$n/a
Mid Priced Plan Namen/an/a
Mid Priced Plan Cost Per Month$n/a$n/a
Top Plan NameCheckMark Payroll Pro+Payroll + HR
Top Plan Cost Per Month$619$14

CheckMark Payroll vs Sage Features

FeaturesCheckMark PayrollSage
Target Business SizeMid size businessMid size business
Unlimited Payrolls✔✘
Automated Tax Filing & Payments✔✔
E-sign I-9 & W-4✘✘
Live Customer Support✔✘
Third-Party Integrations✔✔
Ability To Manage Employee Benefits✔✔
Employee Access To Platform✔✔
Direct Deposit✔✘
Expense Reimbursement✔✔
Time Off Accrual✔✔
Pre-Tax Deductions✔✘
Wage Garnishment✔✔
Background Checks✘✘
Check Printing✔✘
Check Delivery✘✘
API✘✔

CheckMark Payroll CheckMark Payroll Pro Features

  • Self Service Payroll
  • Automatic Payroll Calculation
  • Unlimited Companies
  • Unlimited Salaried & Hourly Employees
  • Unlimited Payrolls (Regular, Bonus, Off-Cycle, etc.)
  • All Pay Frequencies
  • Multiple Pay Rates
  • MICR Encoded Check Printing
  • ACH Direct Deposit
  • Printing & E-Filing of Forms 941, 940, 944, 943, W-2, & W-3
  • Employer Payroll Tax Filings
  • Access to 40+ Types of Payroll Reports
  • Employee Benefits (Health, Retirement, Insurance, etc.)
  • Customized Vacation and Sick Leave Policies
  • Customized Deductions and Garnishments
  • Up to 90 mins within 12 months
  • Online access to program fixes

Sage Payroll Features

  • Payroll
  • Payroll reporting
  • Employee self-serve
  • Tax filing and tax payments
  • Year end (T4/Relevé – 1)
  • Garnishment calculations
  • Record of employment
  • Statment of remittances
  • Timesheets
  • Basic HR reporting
  • Digital employee records
  • Regulatory and custom policies
  • Basic document storage for employees
  • 3rd party integrations

CheckMark Payroll CheckMark Payroll Pro+ Features

  • Self Service Payroll
  • Automatic Payroll Calculation
  • Unlimited Companies
  • Unlimited Salaried & Hourly Employees
  • Unlimited Payrolls (Regular, Bonus, Off-Cycle, etc.)
  • All Pay Frequencies
  • Multiple Pay Rates
  • MICR Encoded Check Printing
  • ACH Direct Deposit
  • Printing & E-Filing of Forms 941, 940, 944, 943, W-2, & W-3
  • Employer Payroll Tax Filings
  • Access to 40+ Types of Payroll Reports
  • Employee Benefits (Health, Retirement, Insurance, etc.)
  • Customized Vacation and Sick Leave Policies
  • Customized Deductions and Garnishments
  • Up to 300 mins of support within 12 months
  • Exclusive Pro+ toll-free phone number
  • Top-of-the-queue priority
  • Reduced data recovery rates
  • Online access to program fixes
  • Exclusive Pro+ Support Live Chat

Sage Payroll + HR Features

  • Payroll
  • Payroll reporting
  • Employee self-serve
  • Tax filing and tax payments
  • Year end (T4/Relevé – 1)
  • Garnishment calculations
  • Record of employment
  • Statment of remittances
  • Timesheets
  • Basic HR reporting
  • Digital employee records
  • Regulatory and custom policies
  • Basic document storage for employees
  • 3rd party integrations
  • Leave management
  • Advanced reporting
  • HR forms and documents management
  • Organization charts
  • Custom workflow builder and automation builder
  • Learning management
  • Asset management
  • HR analytics
  • Company announcements
  • Manager reports
  • Onboarding and offboarding flows

CheckMark Payroll vs Sage Pro & Cons

CheckMark PayrollSage
Pros
  • Direct deposit option
  • Easy to use and interfaces with CheckMark’s Accounting program, MultiLedger
  • Automated reports
  • User Friendly
  • Customizable
  • User Interface
Cons
  • Technical support, glitches with Mac
  • High cost
  • More features like direct sms, email, other tax purpose forms
  • Reporting Issues
  • Expensive
  • Product Limitations
  • User Interface

Other Payroll Software Comparisons